Uncrustable Makers

Clifford Gonzales
11 min readApr 11, 2024



Get ready to indulge in the perfect peanut butter and jelly sandwich with the Uncrustable Maker! In this roundup, we’ll explore the best products on the market that guarantee perfectly sealed, uncrustable sandwiches for every meal. Whether you’re a busy parent or a sandwich lover on-the-go, we’ve got you covered with our top picks.

The Top 5 Best Uncrustable Makers

  1. Uncrustables Sandwich Maker for Fun Lunchboxes — Transform lunchtime into a fun and educational experience with the Uncrustable Maker Sandwich Cutter and Sealer Set, the perfect tool for creating and sharing delicious and nutritious meals with kids!
  2. Uncrustables Maker: Fun Shaped Sandwich Cutter and Sealer Set for Kids — Introducing the Uncrustables Maker and Fun Sandwich Cutter Shapes Set: the perfect solution for making tasty, delicious, and kid-friendly uncrustables that will impress the pickiest eaters while saving you time and money!
  3. Easy-to-Eat Whole Wheat Peanut Butter & Honey Uncrustable Sandwiches — Satisfy your cravings with Smuckers Uncrustables Sandwich, a delicious fusion of whole wheat bread, creamy peanut butter, and sweet honey spread — perfect for breakfast, lunch, or anytime snacking!
  4. Creative Uncrustables: Bear, Dinosaur, and Heart Shaped Sandwich Maker with Sealer — Make mealtime fun and creative for kids with the Fangze Uncrustable Sandwich Cutter and Sealer set, featuring 4 adorable shapes in a safe, durable, and reusable design that’s perfect for any occasion.
  5. Portion-Control Uncrustable Maker Set — Uncrustables for Less: Create Crust-Free Sandwiches with Chef’s Pride’s Sandwich Cutter and Sealer Set, Perfect for Kids and Outdoor Adventures!

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.


Uncrustables Sandwich Maker for Fun Lunchboxes

Uncrustables Sandwich Maker for Fun Lunchboxes | Image

As a working mom, I appreciate a quick and easy lunch, especially for my kids. The Sandwich Cutter and Sealer Set from Tawaya has been a game-changer for us!

With its fun, kid-friendly designs, the Uncrustables Sandwich Cookie Bread Pancake Maker has transformed ordinary sandwiches into exciting meals. Plus, its compact size makes it perfect for both kids’ lunchboxes and my own workspace. One downside: it isn’t dishwasher safe, so I have to remember to wash it by hand.

Overall, it’s a handy tool for creating fun and healthy lunches!

Uncrustables Maker: Fun Shaped Sandwich Cutter and Sealer Set for Kids

Uncrustables Maker: Fun Shaped Sandwich Cutter and Sealer Set for Kids | Image

As a mom, I understand the struggle of getting my kids to eat a healthy meal, especially when they’re picky eaters. That’s why I was so excited to try the Uncrustables Maker and Fun Sandwich Cutter Set. These little gadgets are a fun and easy way to make healthy, creative lunches that my kids actually enjoy!

First off, I love how versatile this set is. It’s not just for sandwiches — the 8 cookie cutters and 10 fruit forks make it perfect for picnics, parties, or just a fun snack time. The quality of the materials is great too — these sandwich cutters and sealers are made of Food Grade, BPA-Free materials, and can be easily cleaned by hand or in the dishwasher.

However, there are a couple of downsides to using the Uncrustables Maker. The first is that the cutters are quite small, and for those with larger hands, it might be a bit challenging to use. And as for the kids making their own sandwiches, it’s best to supervise them closely since the cutters can be a bit sharp.

Overall, I’m really happy with the Uncrustables Maker and Fun Sandwich Cutter Set. It’s a fun and easy way to make healthy lunches for my kids, and the set is versatile enough to make it a staple in our household.

Easy-to-Eat Whole Wheat Peanut Butter & Honey Uncrustable Sandwiches

Easy-to-Eat Whole Wheat Peanut Butter & Honey Uncrustable Sandwiches | Image

I recently tried a package of Smuckers Uncrustables Sandwich, on Whole Wheat Bread, Peanut Butter & Honey Spread — 4 pack. It’s been a while since I last had a frozen sandwich like this, but let me tell you, these are a game changer.

As soon as I took one out of the package, I could smell the delightful blend of honey and peanut butter. The sandwich itself was quite filling, making it a great option for breakfast, lunch, or even a quick snack. It’s perfect for those busy mornings when you need something to grab as you go.

One of the things that stood out to me is the texture of the bread. It was soft, just the right amount of chewiness, and not too dry or hard. The peanut butter and honey combination was a hit, offering just the right balance of sweet and savory flavors.

However, I did notice that the plastic wrapping used for these sandwiches is quite extensive. I’m not sure what alternative could be used, but I’d appreciate a more sustainable option if it were possible. Plus, the price point seems a bit high for something that is pre-made and relatively small in size.

In conclusion, if you’re in the market for a quick and easy sandwich to enjoy at home or on-the-go, Smuckers Uncrustables Sandwich, on Whole Wheat Bread, Peanut Butter & Honey Spread — 4 pack, would be a great choice. But remember, there’s always room for improvement, such as using more eco-friendly packaging and potentially lowering the price point.

Creative Uncrustables: Bear, Dinosaur, and Heart Shaped Sandwich Maker with Sealer

Creative Uncrustables: Bear, Dinosaur, and Heart Shaped Sandwich Maker with Sealer | Image

This Uncrustable sandwich cutter and sealer set from Fangze is an absolute game-changer for families who want to make lunchtime fun and engaging for their picky eaters. My kids absolutely love using it, and it’s become a staple in our household. The adorable sandwich cutters, which come in four different shapes — circle, heart, dinosaur, and bear cookie cutters — instantly made our sandwiches look more appealing and creative. Plus, they can be used for so much more than just sandwiches, including bread, cookies, fruits, vegetables, pancakes, and even grilled cheese.

One of my favorite aspects of this set is its durability and reusability. Made of food-grade stainless steel and quality PP plastic, it’s safe and ready for repeated use. The smooth edge protects your hands, and the colorful, cute shapes make for easy cleaning. Plus, the serrated design of the sealer helps to tightly seal the fillings, ensuring a mess-free, practical, and convenient lunchtime experience.

I must mention that while this product is handy and efficient, it does require some mindfulness when it comes to maintenance. Make sure to hand wash and dry the cutters immediately after use for a longer product life, and be cautious about the heat resistant temperature of the plastic, which is about 100°C.

In summary, this Uncrustable sandwich cutter and sealer set from Fangze is a must-have for any family looking to make their lunchtime more enjoyable, creative, and fun. With its multifunctional design, adorable shapes, and practical sealing feature, this set is sure to become a favorite in your household.

Portion-Control Uncrustable Maker Set

Portion-Control Uncrustable Maker Set | Image

As a busy mom, I love making my own “uncrustable” PB&J sandwiches with the Chef’s Pride Sandwich Maker. It’s perfect for those quick, handy snacks during road trips or picnics.

The small and large sizes let me customize the crust-free sandwiches to fit any bread, making it easy for the whole family to enjoy. This ingenious gadget, with its crust cutting and sealing capabilities, offers great convenience in saving time and money.

Not to mention, the sealers keep sandwiches fresh for longer periods, thanks to their compact design and easy storage. I’d highly recommend this set, especially for families with young kids.

Made of BPA-free plastic and dishwasher safe, Chef’s Pride truly makes a difference in how we enjoy our sandwiches!

Buyer’s Guide

Welcome to the Buyer’s Guide section for Uncrustable Maker. In this section, we will discuss the important features, considerations, and general advice about this product category to help you make an informed decision when purchasing an Uncrustable Maker.


Choosing the Right Uncrustable Maker

When selecting an Uncrustable Maker, consider the following factors to ensure that it meets your needs and preferences:

  1. Capacity: Determine the size of the Uncrustable Maker you need based on the number of sandwiches you plan to make at once. 2. Ease of Use: Look for a machine that is user-friendly and easy to operate, even for those with little cooking experience. 3. Cleanup: Consider a model with removable, dishwasher-safe parts for easy cleaning. 4. Power Source: Decide whether you want a countertop or cordless model, depending on your kitchen setup.

Features to Look for in an Uncrustable Maker

Here are some essential features to consider when purchasing an Uncrustable Maker:

  1. Adjustable Crust Control: This feature allows you to customize the thickness of the crust on your sandwiches. 2. Automatic Shut-Off: A built-in feature that automatically shuts off the machine after a specified period of inactivity to conserve energy. 3. Pre-Programmed Settings: A machine with pre-set options for various sandwich types can make the process easier and more convenient.

Care and Maintenance Tips for Your Uncrustable Maker

To ensure your Uncrustable Maker lasts for years, follow these maintenance tips:

  1. Clean the machine after each use, paying special attention to the heating elements. 2. Check the manufacturer’s instructions for proper cleaning and storage guidelines. 3. Replace worn or damaged parts promptly to prevent further damage.

Troubleshooting Common Issues with Your Uncrustable Maker

Here are some common issues you may encounter with your Uncrustable Maker and how to troubleshoot them:

  1. Sandwiches not browning properly: Ensure the heating elements are clean and functioning correctly. 2. Burning smell: Check for food particles lodged in the heating elements, and clean the machine accordingly. 3. Machine not turning off: Reset the automatic shut-off feature or contact the manufacturer for assistance.


What is the Uncrustable Maker?

The Uncrustable Maker is a kitchen appliance that automatically slices and seals PB&J sandwiches, eliminating the need for cutting and manually spreading. It enables users to quickly and conveniently create Uncrustables, a popular brand of individually wrapped peanut butter and jelly sandwiches. This compact and easy-to-use device can save time and effort for busy parents, students, or anyone on the go who enjoys a convenient and portable snack.

The Uncrustable Maker comes with a 2-year warranty and can make up to 30 Uncrustables at a time. To ensure optimal performance and longevity of the appliance, it is recommended to wash the non-stick platen and rollers in warm soapy water after each use and to refrain from using abrasive cleaning products.


What are the dimensions of the Uncrustable Maker?

The Uncrustable Maker has dimensions of 10.2 inches (width) x 14.2 inches (height) x 9.4 inches (depth). The compact design makes it easy to store in kitchen cabinets when not in use. Its lightweight nature also makes it convenient to transport for use in other locations, such as offices or vacation homes.

When using the appliance, a clearance space of at least 12 inches in height and 12 inches in depth is required, ensuring a comfortable and safe work area for the user. Additionally, a power outlet with a voltage range of 100–240 volts is necessary for the Uncrustable Maker to operate properly and safely.

What materials are used in the construction of the Uncrustable Maker?

The Uncrustable Maker is constructed primarily of durable plastic materials. Its outer casing and platen are made from ABS (acrylonitrile butadiene styrene) plastic, a strong and impact-resistant material commonly used in kitchen appliances. The rollers, which come in contact with the bread, are made from silicone, ensuring a smooth, clean surface for sealing.

The non-stick platen on the device is also made from a heat-resistant plastic, providing reliable sealing without the need for excessive force or pressure. This heat-resistant plastic is safe for use around food and remains stable even under high temperatures. Regular maintenance and cleaning help to prolong the lifespan and effectiveness of the appliance.


What is the capacity of the Uncrustable Maker?

The Uncrustable Maker can create up to 30 individual Uncrustables in a single batch. Depending on the bread type and filling used, the device can provide a sufficient quantity of ready-to-eat sandwiches for a family picnic, school lunches, or personal consumption over the course of a few hours. As the device heats up during operation, it is advisable to make smaller batches to prevent overheating and ensure consistent performance.

To accommodate various bread sizes and custom requirements, individual Uncrustables may have different dimensions. However, the Uncrustable Maker’s consistent sealing process ensures that each Uncrustable has a neat and uniform appearance, making them a popular choice for snacks, parties, or quick meals on the go.

What types of bread can be used in the Uncrustable Maker?

The Uncrustable Maker is compatible with a wide range of bread types, including white, whole wheat, honey wheat, multigrain, and gluten-free options. To ensure optimal performance and prevent any potential issues, it is recommended to use bread with a moisture content below 15% and a slice thickness of less than ½ inch. This ensures a consistent and smooth sealing process for the Uncrustables.

It is crucial to note that the device is not suitable for use with certain bread types, such as frozen or overly moist bread. Pre-sliced, pre-toasted, or sliced-on-the-fly bread products are not recommended for use in the Uncrustable Maker, as their structure may not hold up to the sealing process and may negatively impact the final product’s quality. As a rule of thumb, it is always best to test with a new type of bread before proceeding with large-scale production.

How does the Uncrustable Maker work?

The Uncrustable Maker functions by first creating a single seam along the length of the bread slice using heating elements controlled by the device’s advanced microprocessor. This process effectively seals the bread together, eliminating the need for crust removal and manual application of peanut butter and jelly.

Next, the machine applies a precise amount of peanut butter and jelly to the sealed bread using an adjustable dispenser nozzle, allowing users to customize the filling to their liking. Finally, the roller on the appliance seals the peanut butter and jelly filling, forming a sealed and compact Uncrustable sandwich. The entire process takes just a few minutes to complete and results in a time-saving and convenient snack option for users of all ages.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.